An unruly crowd clash with police, Tuesday, July 30, 2024, in Southport, northwest England, near where three girls were stabbed to death in a dance class the day before. The violence erupted shortly after a peaceful vigil was attended by hundreds in the center of Southport to mourn the 13 victims of the stabbings, including seven still in critical condition.
| Photo Credit: AP
The British government has called on Elon Musk to act responsibly after the tech billionaire used his social media platform X to unleash a barrage of posts that officials say risk inflaming the violent unrest gripping the country.
Justice Minister Heidi Alexander made the comments Tuesday morning (August 6) after Mr. Musk posted a comment saying that “Civil war is inevitable” in the U.K. Mr. Musk later doubled down, highlighting complaints that the British criminal justice system treats Muslims more leniently than far-right activists and comparing Britain’s crackdown on social media users to the Soviet Union.
“Use of language such as a ‘civil war’ is in no way acceptable,’’ Ms. Alexander told Times Radio. “We are seeing police officers being seriously injured, buildings set alight, and so I really do think that everyone who has a platform should be exercising their power responsibly.’’
Britain has been shaken by violence for more than a week, as police clashed with crowds spouting anti-immigrant and Islamophobic slogans in cities and towns from Northern Ireland to the south coast of England. The unrest began after right-wing activists used social media to spread misinformation about a knife attack that killed three girls during a Taylor Swift-themed dance event on July 29.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer, who has described the riots as “far-right thuggery,” on Monday (August 5) said the government would deploy a “standing army” of specialist police officers to quell the unrest.
But the government is also calling on social media companies, such as Mr. Musk’s X, formerly known as Twitter, to do more to combat the spread of misleading and inflammatory information online.
Ms. Alexander said Tuesday that the government would look at strengthening the existing Online Safety Act, which was approved last year and won’t be fully implemented until 2025.
“We’ve been working with the social media companies, and some of the action that they’ve taken already with the automatic removal of some false information is to be welcomed,” Ms. Alexander told the BBC. “But there is undoubtedly more that the social media companies could and should be doing.”
That type of rhetoric may be part of what sparked Mr. Musk’s attack on the government. Mr. Musk has taken a more combative approach to his critics than was the norm in Silicon Valley technology firms, said Alex Krasodomski, who studies the intersection between technology and politics at Chatham House, a London-based think tank.
“He has sparred with U.K. and EU policymakers in the past when they have questioned his approaches to content moderation on the platform,” Mr. Krasodomski said.
X didn’t respond to an email seeking comment. It rarely responds to media requests.
Mr. Musk just kept wading into the debate about the violence in Britain.
After Starmer posted a comment on X saying that the government “will not tolerate attacks on mosques or on Muslim communities,” Mr. Musk responded with the question, “Shouldn’t you be concerned about attacks on all communities?”
Mr. Musk attached a similar comment to a video that said it showed a “Muslim patrol” attacking a pub in Birmingham, highlighting the original post for his 193 million followers.
Such comments are vintage Mr. Musk, who has a history of making provocative statements, said Stephanie Alice Baker, a sociologist at City University of London who has studied online discourse. Mr. frequently comments on geopolitical issues and his fans come to his defense when he is criticized, Ms. Baker said.
Earlier this year, he clashed with a Brazilian supreme court justice over free speech, far-right accounts and purported misinformation on X. He also accused Venezuela’s socialist President, Nicolás Maduro, of “major election fraud” after last week’s disputed election.
Those comments are closely watched by a group of people attracted by his success in business, Ms. Baker said.
“Mr. Musk’s following represents the cult of the entrepreneur …” she said. “By questioning convention, they are depicted as gifted visionaries, who can predict the future and bring it into being. For his fans and followers, Mr. Musk’s impulsive comments are perceived as part of his genius.”